Skip to main content

The Place of Personal Piety



Ask virtually any evangelical Christian, “What is the single most important question in life?” and the response will likely be, “Do you have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ?”  Most of our ministries are designed in some way to pose that question and cultivate a personal response from the people we serve.  Many Evangelicals have conversion stories that include strong “before and after” descriptions.  Some even expect that such a narrative should be normative for all Christians.

The Watergate cover-up conspiracy of the early 1970’s may have brought down an American president but it also formed a backdrop for the conversion of Chuck Colson, who was one of Evangelicalism’s most respected leaders in the twentieth century.  Colson, a retired Marine officer, was President Nixon’s “hatchet man.”  He was a master of dirty tricks targeting the administration’s political enemies.  His involvement in Watergate plunged him into a personal crisis which became a catalyst for his conversion to Christianity.  The press mocked his new-found faith as a ploy for sympathy and leniency for his misdeeds.  But after thirty-five years of radical personal change and tireless service through Prison Fellowship, the ministry he founded, Colson’s life demonstrated the transformational power of the “born-again” experience.[1]

Prior to the Reformation, the Church rarely used the term, “born again.”  For Catholic and Orthodox theologians, regeneration happens at baptism.  But for the modern Evangelical, being born again is a cognizant experience that is essential for salvation.  Everyone must personally and willingly respond to the gospel.  The necessity of having and nurturing a personal relationship with Christ drives virtually all that we do.  The imperative of personal conversion is the reason we are so passionate about missions, both locally and around the world.  Evangelicals emphasize holiness, discipline, and good works as evidence of a personal relationship with Christ.  We affirm the Bible as God’s Word and as his revelation of the salvation which can only be found through Jesus Christ.  Our commitment to Scripture places a high value on personal reading and devotion, Bible-centered preaching, and the establishment of societies for the distribution of God’s Word. 

Because we value a personal relationship with Christ so highly, we tend to be suspicious of the institutional Church with all its historic worship practices, such as set prayers, liturgies, and creeds.  Evangelicals tend to resist words being put into our mouths.  We like to improvise our own prayers and thoughts as a reflection of the authenticity of our personal faith.  That being the case, many Evangelicals might be shocked to learn that the roots of our movement can be traced back to seventeenth and eighteenth century Lutheran Pietism, where the values we hold today were firmly embraced and institutionalized in Halle, Germany.

An Unsung Evangelical Hero
August Hermann Franke (1663-1727) had prepared himself for vocational ministry.  Already educated and credentialed as a Lutheran pastor, he sensed that he was missing the mark as a “true Christian.”  In 1687, he received a new opportunity in Luneburg, Germany, where he would spend his time in private study and fellowship with devout and pious Christians.  Shortly after his arrival, he was asked to preach at the local church. He was instructed that the sermon must be directed to the heart and conscience of the hearer. His text was John 20:31: “[These signs]…are written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in His name.”  Preparation for the sermon drove him to despair:

…as I now pondered this with all seriousness, it came to me that I possessed no such faith as I demanded.  I thus came away from meditation on the sermon and found enough to do within myself because such, namely that I still had no true faith, came deeper and deeper into my heart.  I wanted to rise immediately and drive these dismal thoughts away, but nothing would suffice.  I was until that time, accustomed to relying on my own reason, with good cause because in my heart I had experienced little of the new reality of the Spirit.[2]

Over the course of several days, Franke’s despair and disbelief deepened.  In pondering the text, he discovered that he had no real faith; that indeed, he did not even believe in God or his Word.  Nevertheless, he persevered in his discipline of prayer and study, not wishing to disappoint those who had asked him to preach.  He was in great distress and sorrow with no refuge of genuine faith in a Savior.  Like Augustine and Luther before him and countless others who would follow, he was in deep despair for his soul when God finally intervened:

In such great anxiety I fell again to my knees on that Sunday eve and cried to God – who I neither knew nor believed – for salvation from such a sorrowful condition, if there was truly a God.  Then the Lord heard me, the living God from his holy throne, as I was still on my knees.…Then, as one turns his hand (in a twinkling), so all my doubts were gone; I was sure in my heart of the grace of God in Jesus Christ; I knew God not only as God, but rather as one called my Father.  All sadness and unrest in my heart was taken away in a moment.  On the contrary, I was suddenly so overwhelmed as with a stream of joy that I praised out of high spirits that God who had shown me such great grace.  I arose again of a completely different mind than when I had knelt down.  I had bent down with great sorrow and doubt, but arose again with inexpressible joy and great assurance.  As I knelt, I did not believe there was a God.  As I arose I would have confirmed it without fear or doubt, even with the shedding of my blood.[3]

Franke was “born again” through the experience which would shape the rest of his life and ministry.  The deep wrestling of his soul would become known as busskampf or “penitential struggle.” While Franke did not prescribe his path as a normative means to be born again, the penitential struggle would become a common theme in conversion narratives for Pietists.[4]

August Hermann Franke should be considered second-generation among Lutheran Pietists, but the ministry that he established at Halle was the pinnacle of achievement and influence for the movement.  F. Earnest Stoeffler, the father of American Pietism scholarship, said this of him: "Franke is undoubtedly one of the most massive figures of the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries in Europe.  As a religious genius he fashioned Spenerian Pietism into one of the most self-assured, theologically compact, as well as dynamic, religious movements of the day."[5]

The Ministry at Halle
The ministry at Halle was wide-ranging.  Franke was particularly moved by the plight of the poor while at the same time cultivating relationships with the ruling elite.  He became friends with his monarch, Frederick Wilhelm I, even though the king was Reformed. He corresponded with Peter the Great of Russia and the influential English Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge.  He had friends in Scandinavia as well as in the American colonies.  Franke’s political skills enabled him to build the support that he needed to develop his ministry.

Halle had a very active printing enterprise.  Between 1712 and 1719, Franke and his enterprise printed 100,000 German Bibles and 80,000 New Testaments.  By comparison, it took Wittenberg, the previous leader in publishing the Scriptures, nearly one hundred years to print and distribute that same number.  Pietists placed a high value on personal Bible reading.  The operation in Halle fulfilled a dream of making the Bible a “book of the people.”  Franke’s business enterprise was not just limited to publishing, however.  The ministry was also supported by a thriving fur and wine import business – made all the more profitable by privileges that he had negotiated with the monarch. Halle’s educational system was comprehensive.  In the university, Franke developed a model for training ministers and teachers that would be worthy of emulation today.  Along with academic rigor in their studies, his students were expected to apply their knowledge and skills in Halle ministry institutions:  orphanages, biblical training for young people (catechism), and schools for all ages and social strata. 

Franke also had a heart for world evangelization.  Foreign leaders looked to him to help supply missionaries for their colonial interests.  When thirty thousand Protestants were driven from the Salzburg region, many of them immigrated to the Georgia Colony in America.  Halle provided ministerial and financial support for the refugees.  Heinrich Melchior Muhlenberg, who established the first organized Lutheran church in Pennsylvania, was sent and financed by Franke.  Halle’s influence was far-reaching and profound.  Swedish pastors who had been trained there promoted spiritual revival among compatriot prisoners in Siberia who, in turn, would influence their homeland when they were finally released.  Franke also had a close and supportive relationship with Count Nicolas Von Zinzendorf, the leader of the Moravians, who were very active in mission work and would eventually play a vital role in the conversions of John and Charles Wesley. 

The entrepreneurial accomplishments of August Hermann Franke were extraordinary.  But at his core, he was a pastor who had a heart that burned with passion for God and His work.  Though politically shrewd, he was uncommonly kind and gentle.  His sermons were unremarkable:  hastily prepared, repetitive, and lacking in illustration.  (Perhaps that is no wonder; he had to prepare and deliver up to five sermons a week along with all of his other duties.)  Still, he was a very popular pastor; his sermons were attended by large crowds.  He abolished group confession in favor of a private interview with the pastor.  Franke insisted that families and the church work together in child-raising, so he reestablished catechism for children and made pastoral visits in homes.  He was charming, transparent, and sincere: a model of authentic Christian faith.  Prior to his conversion, Franke had sought to become a “true Christian.”  By all accounts, he did not miss the mark....


The preceding excerpt was taken from Strategic Portraits: People and Movements That Shaped Evangelical Worship.  The remaining portion of the chapter explains how Pietism has deeply shaped Evangelicalism and analyzes its strengths and liabilities in corporate worship.  You can order your copy of the book from Amazon in print or Kindle format. 



[1] Colson’s testimony is told in his first published book, Born Again. (Grand Rapids: Chosen Book, 1976).
[2] As quoted in Gary R. Sattler, God’s Glory, Neighbor’s Good, (Chicago:  Covenant Press, 1982) 29.
[3] Ibid., 31.
[4] Penitential struggle prior to conversion did become the norm in the American First Great Awakening.  Jonathan Edwards describes the suffering of those seeking salvation in New England as did David Brainerd in his ministry with the Indians.   One hundred years later, under Charles Finney’s influence, the process of conversion would no longer include the expectation of busskampf.
            [5] F. Earnest Stoeffler, German Pietism in the Eighteenth Century, (Leiden, Netherlands: E.J. Brill, 1973) 36. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Revival of Hymns Could Help

Like most pastors, I’m considering what it might look like when our congregation is able to gather again.   In the online discussions that I have participated in, some have suggested that the congregation not sing.   It may be that the prohibition against singing is even mandated in some places. Such a prohibition is hard for me accept.   But I get it.   Singing takes more breath energy than speaking and the “particles” that inevitably fly from one’s mouth when singing (especially when it is in German!) may travel more than the prescribed six-foot social distancing boundary.   Still, as a life-long church musician, that is a hard pill to swallow.   As I’ve pondered this, I wondered if singing acapella at a soft level might be an effective compromise.   As a choral musician, I know that some of the most poignant moments are often when the choir is singing very softly.   I can imagine that a congregation singing hymns softly would have a profound effect.   Why hymns?  

Revivalism's Legacy

“Lord, whence are those blood-drops all the way   That mark out the mountain’s track?” “They were shed for one who had gone astray   Ere the Shepherd could bring him back.” “Lord, whence are Thy hands so rent and torn?” “They’re pierced tonight by many a thorn.”                                         “The Ninety and Nine”                Words by Elizabeth C. Clephane, 1868           Music spontaneously improvised by Ira. D. Sankey, 1874 I was only five years old when my brother told me I was going to hell.   Older brothers are like that.    He had just prayed to receive Christ as his personal Savior in Sunday School and was pleased to inform me of my fate since I had not yet “prayed the sinner’s prayer.”   This, of course, was very upsetting to me and I went crying to my mom.   She explained salvation to me as best she could for a five-year-old to understand and led me in the prayer.   This put my brother at bay for a while and ruined his fun.   My mom was